Wills & Estates
Estate Disputes & Family Provision Lawyers
Change cityChoose your city
Melbourne legal advice on contested wills, family provision claims and estate dispute resolution.
Understanding Estate Disputes & Family Provision Claims
Estate disputes are often emotionally charged because they sit at the intersection of grief, family history and money. Some claims are about adequate provision. Others are about validity, capacity, undue influence, informal testamentary intentions or disputes between executors and beneficiaries.
Vitt Legal advises Melbourne claimants, executors and beneficiaries on estate disputes with a focus on evidence, time limits and realistic resolution. Many matters resolve through negotiated settlement or mediation, but the strategy should still be built as if the claim may need to be defended or pursued formally.
What We Handle
How We Handle Your Matter
Claim or defence assessment
We review the will, family circumstances, estate value and relevant evidence to assess viability and risk.
Evidence preparation
We gather financial, medical and family history material needed to support or defend the dispute.
Mediation and negotiation
We pursue settlement strategically, usually before the matter becomes more expensive than necessary.
Court pathway
If needed, we prepare and run the matter through the Supreme Court with a clear evidentiary case theory.
Why Choose Vitt Legal
We combine estate planning insight with dispute experience
We give candid advice about claim strength, cost and likely settlement range
We prepare evidence carefully around family circumstances and estate value
We understand the need for sensitivity without losing litigation discipline
Related Legal Services
Legal matters often intersect with other areas of law. Explore these related services:
Free Tools for Estate Disputes & Family Provision Claims
Estate disputes need clarity early
We help Melbourne clients assess family provision and contested will claims quickly so the estate and the evidence are protected.
Frequently Asked Questions: Estate Disputes & Family Provision Claims
Under the Administration and Probate Act 1958 (Vic), eligible persons include:
- The spouse or domestic partner at the time of the deceased's death
- Children, including adopted and stepchildren
- Individuals who believed the deceased was their parent and were treated as such
- Former spouses or domestic partners under certain conditions
- Grandchildren or members of the deceased's household who were dependent on the deceased
Estate disputes can be costly — here's what to budget for. Costs can include legal fees, court fees, and potential costs awarded to the other party if the claim is unsuccessful. Some firms offer no win, no fee arrangements, but it's essential to understand the terms fully.
Here's what the court actually looks at when deciding a family provision claim:
- The nature of the relationship between the applicant and the deceased
- The applicant's financial resources and needs
- Any physical, mental, or intellectual disabilities of the applicant
- The size and nature of the estate
- Competing claims from other beneficiaries
While not mandatory, engaging a lawyer experienced in wills and estates is highly recommended. They can provide guidance on eligibility, grounds for contesting, and represent you in court proceedings.
Outcomes may include:
- Provision of a larger share of the estate to the applicant
- Alteration of the distribution among beneficiaries
- Dismissal of the claim, leaving the original will intact
A TFM claim must be filed within six months from the date of the grant of probate or letters of administration. Extensions may be granted in certain circumstances, but prompt action is advisable.
Grounds include:
- The deceased had a moral duty to provide for the applicant
- The applicant was not adequately provided for in the will
- Factors such as the applicant's financial needs, relationship with the deceased, and any disabilities
Yes, if it's believed that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity due to mental health issues, the will's validity can be challenged. Evidence must show the deceased did not understand the implications of their will at the time of its creation.
To reduce the risk:
- Ensure the will is properly drafted and executed
- Clearly outline reasons for any unequal distributions
- Regularly update the will to reflect current intentions
- Consider including a no-contest clause, though its enforceability varies
To contest a will means to legally challenge its provisions, typically on the grounds that the deceased did not make adequate provision for certain individuals. In Victoria, this is known as a Testator's Family Maintenance (TFM) claim.
Expert Legal Help
Estate disputes need clarity early
We help Melbourne clients assess family provision and contested will claims quickly so the estate and the evidence are protected.

